If the future in Iraq looks dismal, someone forgot to tell the Iraqis


Posted by run n gun ® , Oct 06,2003,14:34   MetroBlab

HERE'S ANOTHER FIRSTHAND REPORT FROM IRAQ saying that things are better than the Big Media coverage makes them sound.
But Big Media is catching on. Here's a story from the Philadelphia Inquirer, and Jonathan Rauch writes:


Consistently, however, observers -- including some I know personally and trust -- return from Iraq reporting that the picture up close is better than the images in the media. Michael O'Hanlon, a Brookings Institution military analyst who is no pushover for the Bush administration, recently came back saying that the quality of the work being done in Iraq by American forces is "stunning."

If the future in Iraq looks dismal, someone forgot to tell the Iraqis. A poll by the Gallup Organization found Iraqis saying, by a 2-to-1 ratio, that Saddam Hussein's ouster was worth the subsequent hardships. A plurality told Gallup (a month ago, when the poll was taken) that Iraq was worse off than before the invasion, but two-thirds expected Iraq to be better off in five years than before the invasion, and only 8 percent expected it to be worse off.

The Bush administration reports that "virtually all" major Iraqi hospitals and universities have been reopened, and hundreds of schools have been rebuilt. As of late September, American fatalities (just over 300), although too numerous, were still only slightly higher than the 293 lost in the 1991 Persian Gulf War.

The bad reasons for viewing this mixed but by no means disastrous situation as a nightmare, a quagmire, or a failure have to do with the fact that a lot of people -- some Europeans, some doves, some partisans -- want President Bush or America or both to fail. Partly that is a result of rancor and opportunism, but it also inheres in a pre-emptive engagement. A war to prevent war is bound to be controversial, and this one created a constituency against itself. http://www.philly.com/mld/philly/6928642.htm


Followups



If the future in Iraq looks rosy, someone forgot to tell this columnist

Re:
If the future in Iraq looks dismal, someone forgot to tell the Iraqis -- run n gun
Posted by fluffy ® , Oct 06,2003,22:06   MetroBlab

"The Bush administration reports that "virtually all" major Iraqi hospitals and universities have been reopened, and hundreds of schools have been rebuilt."

so are you saying that the media shouldnt question the bush administration's assertions, or that the bush administration is a reliable source of news media? either way, your shit is wack.

when Clinton said he didnt have sexual relations with that woman, i guess the media should have taken his word for it and left it alone, huh?

something i think that is funny about Runny's posting of military letters claiming all is going better than the media is reporting is that, as LilAmy has said before, military personnel arent supposed to speak out against these kinds of things. naturally if a site was posting letters of troops with their names attached to them for the whole world to see, dont you think that higher ranking military folks would be watching to see if anyone raised a question against this war, and said troop could and would be reprimanded for speaking out? so there in and of itself proves that any letter that is posted supporting the war by a troop is questionable and to be taken with a grain of salt as far as honest feelings about the occupation goes.

"If the future in Iraq looks dismal, someone forgot to tell the Iraqis."

maybe this guy should be noticing the papers, magazines, TV and radio reports that have daily accounts of problems in Iraq. the UN is pulling out more of its personnel, very few nations have agreed to help out still, W's ratings are still going down due to a myriad of back-peddling and blase' rhetoric, about half of americans are still saying this war was the wrong idea, and the MAJORITY of americans are STILL saying, "fuck Iraq, where's our jobs?!?"


G.O. would be proud

Re:
If the future in Iraq looks dismal, someone forgot to tell the Iraqis -- run n gun
Posted by spinetingler ® , Oct 06,2003,15:16   MetroBlab

>A war to prevent war