an officer speaks out


Posted by fluffy ® , Sep 23,2003,11:50   MetroBlab

Sgt. Leanne Duffy: With no plan apparent, GIs in Iraq slowly becoming frantic

By SGt. Leanne Duffy
September 23, 2003

I am a National Guardsman of the 105th Personnel Services Detachment out of Lincoln, Neb. My unit and I are stationed in Kuwait at Camp Wolf. We were deployed Feb. 2. We arrived in Jordan in April and half of us were moved a week later to Kuwait to throw mail.

When our unit came back together in June we had an order to go home but it was revoked and we ended up replacing an active Army unit. When replacing the active unit we were told our date to go home was Dec. 1.

We now hear that we will be here for a full year. We are under 3rd Personnel Command. They say that when they decide who stays and who goes, it's not by how long soldiers have been deployed, just by unit necessity.

My unit processes incoming soldiers and helps soldiers redeploy for theater. We are doing a great job and are working hard to treat each soldier with care and consideration as they come past our desks. They have spread our 44 soldiers out to replace an active unit that had over 50 and to replace a National Guard unit that had over 60 soldiers. Not only are we running 24-hour operations seven days a week for these two units, but we have four of our soldiers on the redeployment side working validation for another unit! We are spread so thin and are working so hard that these knocks on our morale are devastating.

Yes, we are physically able to finish our mission, but mentally and spiritually we are dying.

If retention for the Army National Guard is of any importance, current members need to have faith in our government and our leaders. Right now, where we are, we can't see anyone taking a stand for the soldiers (as it isn't just us being treated this way but many, many soldiers).

This isn't a simple board game of Axis and Allies, this is a game people are playing with real people - people with families, not robots. You have college students out here (like me) missing over a year of college to sit and get yanked around without explanation. It has been told to the officers I have spoken to that 3rd PERSCOM refers to moving soldiers as "drug deals." You do this for me and I'll make sure your soldiers go home, etc.

Yes, without a doubt my duty is to serve my country despite her faults. I have learned I will not be able to get education and training services while I am here and I am accepting that. I am here to serve out of obligation and duty. What I'm wondering is if there are any checks and balances for those who are making decisions here?

Everyone keeps saying it is up in the air, including the personnel responsible for deciding who is going where. It feels as if every decision is off the cuff. In this situation there should be plans in place and decisions made before the rubber hits the road.

We are slowly becoming frantic. I hear people saying they are going to begin hurting themselves or others if they can't go home. The helplessness our soldiers are feeling is indescribable, it is past the point of "suck it up and drive on." We just want somewhere to drive on to.

Thank you for allowing me to bend your ear.

Sgt. Leanne Duffy is from Superior, Neb. E-mail: [email protected].

http://www.madison.com/captimes/opinion/column/guest/57361.php



Followups



an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- fluffy
Posted by hard69rock ® , Sep 24,2003,01:39   MetroBlab

First of all, a SGT is not an officer. Second, it is pretty normal for people deployed for a long time to get home sick and just want to go home. This is not typical or a majority of the military and should not be presented as such.


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- hard69rock
Posted by fluffy ® , Sep 24,2003,07:14   MetroBlab

i guess youve missed the many other articles talking about troop morale as well. or how the predominant question everyone asked Rummy when he was over there last was "when are we coming home?". besides, i never said it was the majority-it was just one Sgt's letter. who said anything about it being the majority view?

an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- fluffy
Posted by hard69rock ® , Sep 24,2003,21:59   MetroBlab

Well, you seem bent on pointing out the one who is unhappy but ignoring the thousands who aren't. When I was in Gulf War 1, after the battle was over we asked when we were going home. But no one was complaining, it was just a question.
I believe I stated that on another post. Perhaps you did not read that one.


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- hard69rock
Posted by fluffy ® , Sep 25,2003,07:20   MetroBlab

"Well, you seem bent on pointing out the one who is unhappy but ignoring the thousands who aren't"

so you are saying that there is only one officer is unhappy?!? thanks for helping me prove how delusional you are. all im doing is providing a counterbalance to people like you and your prez that keep covering your ears while proclaiming "everythings fine! no problems!"

"When I was in Gulf War 1, after the battle was over we asked when we were going home"

yep, and bush declared it over months ago too. but yet still we have a lot of troops over there, and a prez requesting an extra $87 billion for a war that he already claimed was done. so its understandable that a lot want to come home from a war that is supposed to be over. W is using the military as a police force, something they shouldnt be doing. of course, if we hadnt of sent them over in the first place we wouldnt be having this discussion at all. these brave soldiers would be home with their families, where they belong.

"But no one was complaining, it was just a question."

as lilamy commented before, you have a habit of painting your statements with a very broad brush. claiming that NO ONE complained is rather megalomaniacal of you, since you think you speak for every person that served in the 1st Gulf War. as ive already pointed out, my post was the letter of one seargant. and yet you say "no one" and "we" a lot. interesting. so, in being the official spokesperson for the entire miilitary, what do you make of the many articles in Time and Newsweek in which quite a few troops grumbled about going home and being against this war. an army of one indeed, since you seem to speak for all of them.




an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- hard69rock
Posted by lilamy ® , Sep 24,2003,07:14   MetroBlab

Well, actually, a SGT is indeed an officer. He or she is a Non-Comissioned Officer or an NCO. And, unless you have a reliable poll of deployed troops from which to pull your information, I would be careful about weilding such a broad brush regarding what is or is not typical of those troops who are deployed right now. I certainly can't speak for the masses of them. But it will be interesting to see how many make their preferences known in the re-enlistment process. How many will vote with their feet and leave the guard/reserve/active duty ranks in the next 1-4 years?
Now - if you do have such a poll, I'd really love to see it. Of course, I'm not sure how reliable it would be. NCOs and the Commissioned officer corps are constrained from making derogatory remarks about our 'powers that be' as it is demoralizing to our subordinates and subversive.

Be well,
lilamy


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- lilamy
Posted by hard69rock ® , Sep 24,2003,22:09   MetroBlab

Speaking as a former United States Air Force Non-commissioned officer, I get your point about the officer thing. Relative, somewhat accurate but lacking in everything else.
If my 14 years of service are not sufficient for you, then so be it.


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- hard69rock
Posted by lilamy ® , Sep 25,2003,00:38   MetroBlab

I appreciate your 14 years of service in the Air Force. Truly, I do. I am wondering what holes you would like me to fill in with the jobe "somewhat accurate but lacking in everything else."
Just like all the rest of the folks on this forum, I, too, have an opinion. I'm not deriding yours, I'm just trying to point out a couple of things from my 23 year Air Force experience 14 of wh ich were as an enlisted person, 9 of which have been an officer. And yes, I am still on active duty and if you think the job I do - training young men and women from the Air Force, Army, Coast Guard, and Navy to provide health care on the front lines as well as in the clinics and hospitals - is not worthy of an opinion - that is your opinion and I'll be here for a couple more years to help ensure you get to express it freely.

Be well,
lilamy


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- lilamy
Posted by hard69rock ® , Sep 25,2003,23:18   MetroBlab

That was the most expressive, polite and politically correct way I have ever been bitched out. I yeild to your greater tact.

My officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- hard69rock
Posted by Michael ® , Sep 26,2003,16:07   MetroBlab

She's awfully damned cute, too.
~m.


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- lilamy
Posted by fluffy ® , Sep 24,2003,07:18   MetroBlab

"the Commissioned officer corps are constrained from making derogatory remarks about our 'powers that be' as it is demoralizing to our subordinates and subversive."

i do seem to remember a comment that an (unnamed of course) officer made in Time or Newsweek about Rummy's visit in iraq a while ago. lets just say he didnt exactly have nice words about rumsfeld.


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- fluffy
Posted by lilamy ® , Sep 24,2003,08:21   MetroBlab

I would venture a guess, Fluffy, that said officer was 'talked to' about those remarks. There was an article shortly after that in the Air Force Times that reminded us of our duty. And that is that any inquiry should be directed to the local Military Public Affairs officer.
I would loved to have been a fly on the wall.


an officer speaks out

Re:
an officer speaks out -- fluffy
Posted by Lysander Spooner ® , Sep 23,2003,15:31   MetroBlab

The military is a toy to be played with. I guess they are just doing what they were trained to do, but while I have an interest in military history, I have had no desire to ever be in the military. I could not in good conscience serve knowing what I know now.